Newsela launched in 2013 with a bold mission: Meaningful classroom learning for every student. Today, our team constantly strives to deliver powerful solutions that inspire our users.
Scary story writing can be more than a Halloween activity. It gives students a high-interest way to practice narrative skills they’ll use all year, like conflict, plot, pacing, and revision.
To teach students to write a scary story, start with mentor texts. Then help them turn a fear or problem into a story conflict, build the rising action, control suspense, and share their work purposefully.
Jump to
[What makes a scary story scary?](id-what)
Key Takeaways
●Scary comes from craft. Monsters, gore, and creepy adjectives do not automatically make a story scary; mood, stakes, tension, and carefully delayed information do more of the work.
●Fear and suspense are different. Fear is what the character or reader experiences, while suspense is the uncertainty and anticipation around what might happen next.
●Mentor texts make the moves visible. When students read once for meaning and reread for craft, they can name the choices authors make and try those choices in their own drafts.
Scary stories are scary because of the way the author constructs the plot, not just the creepy details, a monster, or a ghost. Before students write, they need to see how authors use setting, stakes, unanswered questions, pacing, and description to evoke fear and suspense in readers.
The key elements of an effective scary story
A scary story doesn’t have to start with a monster or a haunted house. Those details can help, but they’re not “scary” all on their own. What matters more is how the writer builds a situation readers want to understand, worry about, and keep reading through.
It also helps to separate fear from suspense. Fear is a feeling, while suspense is uncertainty that keeps readers anticipating what will happen.
What students should notice in a scary story
Use this checklist as students reread mentor texts for craft. The goal is to help them name the choices writers make before they try those moves in their own drafts.
✓
Setting creates mood.
Students can point to details that make a place feel tense, strange, isolated, or uncertain.
✓
The character gives readers a reason to care.
Students can explain what the character wants, fears, risks, or needs to protect.
✓
The conflict has meaningful stakes.
Students can identify the problem and explain why it matters to the character.
✓
Questions stay unanswered long enough to build suspense.
Students can name what the reader knows, what the reader does not know yet, and why that gap creates tension.
✓
Details build toward a climax.
Students can track how rising tension, pacing, foreshadowing, or sensory details make the problem harder to ignore.
✓
The ending connects to a larger idea.
Students can explain whether the ending resolves the fear, complicates it, or points back to the story’s theme.
[How do you teach students to write a scary story?](id-how)
Key Takeaways
●Read like a writer. Students should move beyond spotting “the scary part” and name the choices the author made to create that effect.
●Build the craft list together. A “Scary Scribe” list works best when students add to it as they analyze mentor texts, not when the teacher hands them every technique upfront.
●Start with a real concern. A fear, problem, or theme gives students a stronger story seed than a random monster or spooky setting.
Students need time to study how authors create fear, try different writing techniques, and turn a real concert or problem into a conflict that can carry a story. To do this well, teach scary story writing as a process rather than a one-day Halloween prompt activity.
Read scary stories like a writer
When reading a spooky mentor text, students shouldn’t just identify “the scary part.” Push them to figure out what the author did to make the moment work, where that move happened, and what the reader knew or didn’t know yet when they got to “the scary part.”
As students work through these questions and ideas, build a “Scary Scribe” craft list together. It’s more useful if the list grows from mentor-text conversations instead of just landing on their desks as a finished handout.
Moves of a Scary Scribe
After mentor-text discussions, students can use this class-built list as a writing handout while they draft.
✓
Create a mood-setting place.What we noticed: Authors use setting details to make a place feel tense, strange, isolated, or uncertain.
Try it: Describe one detail in the setting that tells readers something is not quite right.
✓
Give readers someone to worry about.What we noticed: A scary moment works better when readers understand what the character wants, fears, or might lose.
Try it: Show what your character cares about before the danger gets worse.
✓
Leave a question unanswered.What we noticed: Suspense builds when readers know enough to worry but not enough to feel certain.
Try it: Let readers hear the sound, see the shadow, or notice the clue before you explain it.
✓
Make the problem harder to ignore.What we noticed: Rising tension happens when the conflict keeps getting harder to escape or solve.
Try it: Add one event that makes your character’s next choice more difficult.
✓
Plant a clue early.What we noticed: Foreshadowing gives readers a small hint that feels more important later.
Try it: Add a detail early in the story that matters again near the climax.
✓
End with meaning.What we noticed: A strong ending resolves, twists, or complicates the fear and points back to a bigger idea.
Try it: Ask what your character or reader understands at the end that they did not understand at the beginning.
Start with a fear, problem, or theme
A strong scary story idea usually starts with an ordinary moment students can connect to: A worry, problem, or lesson people might need to learn. From there, they can ask what could go terribly wrong or make the moment strange, and turn the answer into the story’s conflict.
The Scary Story Contest: Theme Thunderstorm lesson helps them work through this line of thinking. Students can explore how fictional monsters and plots reflect real-world fears, then brainstorm theme ideas and conflicts for their own stories.
Turn a real concern into a scary story idea
Students can use this pattern to move from a real-world worry to a story conflict with a larger idea underneath it.
Real concern
Scary-story twist
Possible theme
Bullying
Cruel words physically disappear from people’s mouths.
Words have consequences.
Too much technology
A phone begins predicting, and then causing, everything its owner does.
Technology shouldn’t control our choices.
Fitting in
A student literally begins changing into everyone they imitate.
Being yourself matters.
Pollution
The things people throw away begin returning.
Actions have consequences.
Turn the conflict into a plot
Once students have their conflict, help them shape it into a plot. They don’t need in-depth lessons on story structure, but they do need to understand how and where the fear grows.
The most useful planning question isn’t “What happens next?” It’s: “What could happen next that would make the situation harder to ignore, escape, or solve?” That question pushes students to build the rising action with purpose rather than stringing together random, unrelated scary events.
Plot diagram for a scary story
Use this plot diagram to help students turn one conflict into a full story. The rising action should make the problem harder to ignore, escape, or solve.
Exposition
Conflict
Rising action
Climax
Resolution
Exposition
What students plan: Introduce the character, setting, and normal world.
Scary-story move: Plant one detail that feels slightly wrong, strange, or out of place.
Conflict
What students plan: Name the problem the character has to face.
Scary-story move: Make sure the problem matters to the character, not just to the plot.
Rising action
What students plan: Add events that make the conflict more difficult.
Scary-story move: Ask, “What could happen next that would make the situation worse?”
Climax
What students plan: Plan the moment when the character confronts the problem.
Scary-story move: Force the character to make a choice, face a fear, or understand the truth.
Resolution
What students plan: Show what changes after the climax.
Scary-story move: End in a way that resolves, twists, or complicates the fear.
[How do writers build suspense in a scary story?](id-suspense)
Key Takeaways
●Suspense depends on delay. Students can build tension by letting readers sense danger before the story explains exactly what is happening.
●Pacing is part of the craft. Sentence length, scene detail, and timing can slow readers down near danger or speed them through a tense reveal.
●The stakes have to matter. A noise, shadow, clue, or secret becomes more suspenseful when readers understand what the character could lose.
Writers build suspense by giving readers a reason to worry, then delaying the answer to what will happen. Students can practice that by controlling pacing, leaving questions unanswered, planting clues, and making each reveal matter to the characters.
Delay the answer
Students may want to reveal the monster, secret, or threat right away. But suspense usually grows when the reader has enough information to worry and not enough information to feel settled.
Ask students, “What could the reader notice before they understand what it means?” This revision move keeps the story going while giving the unknown elements time to work. It’s also the difference between suspense and surprise. Surprise is a sudden reveal, but suspense is the stretch of time between noticing something and learning its meaning.
Before students reveal the answer
Use this checklist when students revise a scary moment that feels too quick, too obvious, or too easy to solve.
✓
Show the clue before the explanation.
Readers notice a sound, shadow, object, message, or change before the story tells them exactly what it means.
✓
Let the character guess wrong.
The character tries to explain the problem in an ordinary way before realizing something stranger is happening.
✓
Make the reader wait one more beat.
The story delays the reveal with an action, a pause, a detail, or a choice that stretches the moment.
✓
Reveal only what the next scene needs.
The writer answers one question but leaves another question open so the reader keeps going.
Control pacing with sentence structure
Sentence length can actually help students control pacing and the feel of suspense. Longer sentences can slow readers down as a character approaches danger. Shorter sentences can make a reveal, realization, or moment of panic land harder.
The key is to connect pacing to the moment. Students shouldn’t just add short sentences because “short sounds scarier.” They need to decide when the reader should wait, when the scene should speed up, and when one brief sentence could stop everything.
Sentence pacing lab
Use this as a quick revision move when a scary moment feels flat, rushed, or too evenly written.
Slow the approach
Stretch anticipation
Use when: The character is moving toward danger.
Try it: Add a longer sentence with sensory details, small actions, or the character’s hesitation.
After the final bell, Jonah walked back to the classroom for his notebook, checking each doorway as the hallway lights clicked off one by one.
Hold the moment
Pause before the reveal
Use when: The reader is about to learn something important.
Try it: Let the character notice one final detail before the story explains what it means.
His notebook was on the teacher’s desk, open to a page he knew had been blank that morning.
Snap the tension
Use a short sentence
Use when: Something changes fast.
Try it: Follow a slower sentence with one short sentence that delivers the sound, movement, or realization.
A new line appeared.
Use foreshadowing
Foreshadowing is a way to build suspense without explaining everything too soon. Teach students to plant a detail early, let it sit in the background, and then bring it back later when the readers understand why it mattered.
The trick is to keep the clue useful but not too obvious. If the detail gives away the ending, it becomes a spoiler. If it never matters again, it’s just decoration. Foreshadowing is also important in mystery stories. Consider expanding mentor text to include that genre, along with traditionally scary stories, for more practice.
Follow the foreshadowing thread
Use this path to help students make an early clue matter later in the story.
1
Plant the clue
Add a small detail early, like an object, sound, message, warning, or behavior that feels normal enough to keep reading past.
2
Let it fade back
Move the story forward so the clue stays in the reader’s mind without stopping the scene to explain it.
3
Bring it back
Return to the clue when the conflict is harder to escape, ignore, or solve.
4
Change its meaning
Reveal why the clue mattered so readers understand the earlier moment in a new way.
Let the reader know something the character doesn’t
Dramatic irony can be a strong tool for suspense for older student writers. The reader knows something important, but the character doesn’t. That gap prompts the reader to anticipate what might happen before the character recognizes the danger.
This move is best suited for older writers because it works when the author doesn’t over-explain. The reader needs just enough information to worry while the character keeps making choices that feel reasonable from their point of view.
Suspense technique
Build suspense with dramatic irony
Use this table-style accordion to help students plan what readers know before the character does.
Story moment
What the reader knows
What the character thinks
The warning
Story moment
A note on the teacher’s desk changes after the character leaves the room.
What the reader knows
The reader saw the note change when no one else was in the classroom.
What the character thinks
The character thinks the note is a prank and keeps following its instructions.
The safe place
Story moment
The character runs toward the locked classroom at the end of the hall.
What the reader knows
The reader knows that classroom is where the strange noise started.
What the character thinks
The character thinks the classroom is the only safe place to hide.
The final choice
Story moment
The character has to decide whether to open the door, answer the phone, or read the message aloud.
What the reader knows
The reader recognizes the same clue from the beginning and understands what it means now.
What the character thinks
The character still believes they can solve the problem by making one ordinary choice.
Teacher move: Have students add one dramatic irony row to their own draft plan: the moment, what readers know, and what the character still misunderstands.
Make the consequences matter
A strange sound in a story isn’t automatically suspenseful. It becomes suspenseful when students connect it to something the character could lose, misunderstand, or fail to protect.
Have students test each scary moment by asking: “What happens if this goes wrong?” If the answer doesn’t matter yet, they probably need higher stakes.
Raise the stakes in a scary moment
Use this sequence to help students turn a spooky detail into a moment that matters.
1
Start with the event
Name what happens: a noise, message, shadow, locked door, missing object, or sudden change.
2
Add what could be lost
Connect the event to something important: safety, trust, time, a friendship, a secret, or a way home.
3
Make the choice harder
Give the character two imperfect options, so doing nothing feels risky and acting also has a cost.
4
Let the outcome echo
Show how the choice changes the next scene, raises a new question, or brings the character closer to the climax.
Use an unreliable narrator
An unreliable narrator is an advanced suspense move, a great one to introduce with high school students. Instead of making the danger obvious, students can prompt readers to question whether the narrator understands the danger, remembers events clearly, or tells the whole truth.
This works best when the reader has a reason to doubt the narrator, not when the writer simply hides information as a trick. Students can build that doubt through contradictions, missing details, strange reactions, or a version of events that other characters seem to question.
Advanced suspense move
How reliable is the narrator?
Use this continuum to help students decide how much readers should trust the narrator’s version of events.
Readers mostly trust the narratorReaders question the narrator
[How can students make a scary story more descriptive?](id-descriptive)
Key Takeaways
●Description should do a job. Strong details make the setting, danger, or character reaction more vivid instead of pausing the story.
●Fear is often shown physically. Movement, breathing, thoughts, dialogue, and what a character notices can reveal fear more effectively than naming the emotion.
●Precise verbs beat extra adjectives. Before students pile on spooky words, have them revise the action so the sentence carries more of the image.
Description should intensify the story, not interrupt it. Students can revise scary story writing by using sensory detail, showing how a character reacts, and choosing precise verbs that make the moment easier for readers to picture and feel.
Have students write with the senses
Sensory details help make a scary scene feel specific. Instead of asking students to “add description,” ask them what their characters hear, see, smell, feel, or notice that they normally wouldn’t.
They don’t have to use every sense in every scene. One or two well-chosen details can do more than a long list of scary adjectives.
Use sensory details to build the moment
Have students choose the details that make the danger feel closer, stranger, or harder to ignore.
Sense
Ask students
How it helps the story
Hear
What sound does the character notice before they know what caused it?
Sound can create suspense before the threat is visible.
See
What looks different, missing, or out of place?
Visual details can plant clues and make the setting feel wrong.
Smell
What smell tells the character something has changed?
A specific smell can make the scene feel more immediate and unsettling.
Feel physically
What happens in the character’s body as the moment gets worse?
Physical reactions can show fear without naming it.
Notice
What small detail would the character ignore on a normal day?
An ordinary detail can become scary when the situation changes.
Teacher move: Ask students to pick one scene and add two sensory details only. Then have them explain what each detail does for the reader.
Describe the character’s reaction instead of naming the emotion
When students write a sentence like “She was scared,” they’re naming the feeling for readers instead of letting the readers experience it for themselves. A stronger revision move is to show fear through:
Movement.
Thoughts.
Breathing.
Physical reactions.
Dialogue.
What characters notice.
These writing moves also keep description connected to action. The character doesn’t pause in the story to announce an emotion. Instead, the exposition shows how fear changes what they do next.
Show the reaction, not the label
Have students choose one named emotion in their draft and revise it into something readers can see, hear, or infer.
Instead of naming fear
Jonah was scared.
Show it through...
Movement
Jonah stepped back from the desk, but his heel caught on a chair leg.
Thoughts
He told himself someone from yearbook had left the message. That had to be it.
Breathing
Every breath sounded too loud in the empty classroom.
Physical reaction
His fingers slipped twice before he could close the notebook.
Dialogue
“Who’s there?” he asked, but the words barely reached the door.
What the character notices
The page was warm, like someone had just finished writing on it.
Choose precise verbs before piling on adjectives
Adjectives can help describe a scary moment, but they shouldn’t do all the work. Before students add more words like “creepy,” “dark,” or “terrifying,” ask them to switch up their verbs. A precise verb can show action, mood, and pace at the same time.
Students can still use adjectives in their writing, but they should make the sentence move first, then add description where it helps.
Try a verb-first revision pass
Use these examples to help students revise a flat scary sentence by strengthening the action first.
Make movement more specific
Before: Jonah walked slowly down the hallway.
Verb-first revision: Jonah edged down the hallway.
Why it works:Edged shows caution without adding a pile of extra description.
Let the setting act
Before: The door was old and scary.
Verb-first revision: The door groaned against the frame.
Why it works:Groaned makes the setting feel active and unsettling.
Make the sound carry tension
Before: There was a loud, scary sound upstairs.
Verb-first revision: Something scraped across the floor upstairs.
Why it works:Scraped gives readers a clearer sound and leaves the cause unanswered.
Show the reaction through action
Before: Jonah was very nervous when he saw the message.
Verb-first revision: Jonah stared at the message until the letters blurred.
Why it works:Stared turns the emotion into something readers can picture.
Teacher move: Have students circle three plain verbs in one scene and replace only one. Then ask which version changes the reader’s experience more.
Revision HTML
Student revision sheet
Scary story revision checklist
Before you edit spelling and punctuation, use this checklist to revise how your story works for the reader.
Name:
Date:
Draft title:
Find the suspense.
Where is the most suspenseful part of your story? Mark it in your draft, then explain why that moment should make readers worry or wonder.
Check when the reader learns information.
Does the reader learn anything too early? Find one place where you could delay information so the question lasts longer.
Make the rising action harder.
Does each major event make the conflict more difficult to ignore, escape, or solve? Add, remove, or reorder one event if the middle feels too easy.
Revise the description.
Can the reader picture and hear the setting? Have you shown how the character reacts instead of only naming the emotion?
Test the ending.
Does the climax resolve the central conflict? Does the ending connect to the larger idea, lesson, or fear underneath the story?
[How should students revise a scary story?](id-revise)
Students should revise their scary stories for effect before they focus on conventions. That means checking whether they’ve built suspense, whether the reader learns information at the right time, whether the rising action gets harder to ignore, and whether the ending connects back to the central conflict or larger idea.
This deserves more attention than most Halloween-writing content gives it.
Student revision sheet
Scary story revision checklist
Before you edit spelling and punctuation, use this checklist to revise how your story works for the reader.
Name:
Date:
Draft title:
Find the suspense.
Where is the most suspenseful part of your story? Mark it in your draft, then explain why that moment should make readers worry or wonder.
Check when the reader learns information.
Does the reader learn anything too early? Find one place where you could delay information so the question lasts longer.
Make the rising action harder.
Does each major event make the conflict more difficult to ignore, escape, or solve? Add, remove, or reorder one event if the middle feels too easy.
Revise the description.
Can the reader picture and hear the setting? Have you shown how the character reacts instead of only naming the emotion?
Test the ending.
Does the climax resolve the central conflict? Does the ending connect to the larger idea, lesson, or fear underneath the story?
[How can I differentiate scary story writing by grade level?](id-differentiate)
You can differentiate scary story writing by changing the craft focus—and not giving every grade band a completely different assignment. Elementary students can focus on a clear problem and the mood, while middle school students can build stronger suspense and rising action. High schoolers are ready for even more complex writing moves like dramatic irony, unreliable narration, and psychological tension.
Grade-level differentiation
Adjust the craft focus by grade band
Use these grade-band shifts to keep the same scary story writing task appropriate, useful, and challenging for different students.
1
Elementary
2
Middle school
3
High school
Primary focus
Elementary
Clear story and mood.
Middle school
Suspense and plot development.
High school
Craft and psychological complexity.
Plot
Elementary
One central problem.
Middle school
Escalating rising action.
High school
Layered conflict.
Suspense
Elementary
Withholding information, sounds, and anticipation.
Middle school
Foreshadowing, pacing, and stakes.
High school
Dramatic irony, unreliable narration, and ambiguity.
Description
Elementary
Sensory details.
Middle school
Imagery and character reactions.
High school
Deliberate imagery, symbolism, and diction.
Theme
Elementary
A simple lesson or message.
Middle school
Fear tied to an issue or problem.
High school
Social or psychological commentary.
Ending
Elementary
Clear resolution or playful twist.
Middle school
Twist or unsettling resolution.
High school
Ambiguous, ironic, symbolic, or psychologically complex ending.
Teacher move: Treat these as starting points, not fixed limits. A student can write above or below the grade-band focus when the mentor text, writing goal, or classroom needs call for it.
These grade band recommendations are starting points and general guidance. A strong middle school writer may be ready to experiment with dramatic irony. A high school class new to narrative writing may need more time with conflict, plot, and sensory detail first. This chart can help you choose a craft target, then pair students with mentor texts that make the target more visible before they draft or revise.
[How can I keep scary story writing age-appropriate and inclusive?](id-age)
Scary story writing is more likely to stay age-appropriate when you set boundaries before students begin drafting. Explain that they want to target suspense, mood, and mystery, not graphic violence or gore.
It also helps to give students more than one track to follow. They can write something:
Scary.
Mysterious.
Strange.
Suspenseful.
Fantasy-themed.
Autumn-themed.
This flexibility can also help you invite scary story writing into the classroom even if your school, students, or their families don’t celebrate Halloween. It keeps the activity grounded in genre and narrative writing rather than the holiday.
Classroom guardrails
Set boundaries before students draft
Use these guardrails to keep scary story writing safe to share, flexible for different classrooms, and focused on craft.
Focus on suspense over gore
Set the line early: Tell students that suspense, mood, unanswered questions, and stakes should do the work.
Limit graphic content: Establish classroom boundaries around violence, gore, and anything that would make peer sharing unsafe.
Offer a craft target: Ask students to make readers worry or wonder, not just react to a shocking detail.
Give students more than one genre lane
Widen the prompt: Let students write a scary, spooky, mysterious, strange, suspenseful, fantasy, or autumn-themed story.
Keep the skill consistent: Students can still practice conflict, plot, pacing, description, and revision even if their story is not Halloween-specific.
Respect classroom context: Consider school expectations and family preferences before framing the assignment around Halloween.
Do not require real fears or trauma
Make personal writing optional: Students should not have to reveal genuine fears, family experiences, or traumatic events to participate.
Use invention instead: A made-up object, setting, mystery, creature, or conflict can still lead to strong suspense.
Separate theme from disclosure: Students can explore a larger idea without turning the story into a personal confession.
Plan for a real classroom audience
Name the audience: Remind students that classmates, teachers, or families may read the final piece.
Use audience as a revision lens: Ask whether the story creates suspense in a way that still feels appropriate to share.
Keep choice available: Give students a private sharing option when classroom publication is not the right fit.
Teacher tip: A quick prewriting boundary talk can save a lot of revision confusion later. Keep the rule simple: suspense is welcome; graphic shock is not the goal.
[How can I assess scary story writing?](id-assess)
You can assess scary story writing by looking at the students’ narrative choices. Rather than just focusing on if the story “feels scary,” you can use a rubric to score the parts that are actually tied to your scary story lessons, like:
Conflict.
Sequence.
Rising action.
Suspense.
Setting.
Mood.
Description.
Theme.
Feedback use.
Conventions.
Teacher scoring guide
Scary story writing rubric
Use this quick rubric to score the story’s craft and give focused next-step feedback.
Scary story writing rubric with criteria for narrative development, writer’s craft, meaning, writing process, and conventions.
Criteria
4Strong
3On track
2Developing
1Needs revision
Narrative development
Clear and earned. Clear conflict; events escalate; climax and resolution feel earned.
Mostly clear. Conflict and sequence are clear; most events build toward the climax.
Uneven. Conflict or sequence is uneven; tension may drop or the ending may feel rushed.
Hard to follow. Conflict is hard to identify; events feel random or the climax/resolution is missing.
Writer’s craft
Craft works together. Suspense techniques, setting, mood, pacing, details, and word choice work together.
Craft is visible. Uses suspense, mood, descriptive details, and purposeful word choice in several places.
Craft needs control. Some craft moves are present, but details, pacing, or word choice need more control.
Mostly tells events. Mostly tells scary events; little use of suspense, mood, description, or pacing.
Meaning
Connected to a larger idea. Character choices and consequences connect clearly to a theme or larger idea.
Theme is present. A theme or lesson is present, and most choices connect to it.
Connection needs development. A larger idea is suggested, but the connection to the story needs development.
Meaning is unclear. The larger idea, lesson, or consequence is unclear.
Writing process
Revision strengthens the draft. Revision clearly strengthens suspense, plot, description, and reader effect; feedback is used.
Revision is evident. Draft shows evidence of revision and some response to feedback.
Revision is limited. Revision is mostly small edits; feedback is used only in limited ways.
Revision is hard to see. Little evidence of revision or response to feedback.
Conventions
Conventions support readability. Sentences, punctuation, spelling, capitalization, and paragraphing support readability.
Errors do not get in the way. Minor errors are present but do not get in the way of meaning.
Errors sometimes distract. Errors sometimes distract or make parts of the story harder to follow.
Errors make reading difficult. Frequent errors make the story difficult to read or understand.
Scroll left to right to see the full rubric.
[Give students a real audience for their scary stories](id-contest)
Students may write differently when they know someone besides their teacher could read their work. A real audience gives their revision a purpose, and getting feedback from others after revision can feel like the payoff for doing the hard work.
If your students are skeptical, prove to them that their work can reach beyond the classroom. Start with the Scariest Stories collection with tales from last year’s Scary Story Contest finalists and semi-finalists. Then, have them read the entries like a contest judge.
Read like a contest judge
After students read a winning or semifinalist story, have them look for the craft moves they might borrow for their own drafts.
✓
Identify the strongest suspense technique.
Name the move the writer used, such as delayed information, foreshadowing, pacing, dramatic irony, stakes, or description.
✓
Find one memorable description.
Explain what the detail helps readers see, hear, feel, or suspect.
✓
Mark where the tension peaks.
Locate the moment when readers have the most reason to worry or wonder what happens next.
✓
Infer the possible theme.
Explain what fear, problem, lesson, or larger idea the story leaves behind.
✓
Borrow one craft move.
Choose one technique the student could try in their own draft without copying the story.
Once they see that other students just like them had their work published, encourage them to enter this year’s contest.
To enter, students will write a 400–1,000-word scary story using the tips covered in this article and the lessons to go with them. You can send their entries to creativewriting.contests@newsela.com by October 20, 2026, for their chance to be featured. Entries should include:
Student’s name.
Grade level.
School district.
Teacher email address.
Without this information, we can’t contact the finalists and semi-finalists.
[Scary story writing lessons and resources for your classroom](id-resources)
These lessons work best as a writing sequence rather than a set of disconnected activities. Together, they give students a path through the full process, from reading mentor texts to publishing (and contest submission!).
You can use the full sequence over several class periods or pull in the lessons that already match where they are in their writing practice to strengthen an activity you already have planned.
Newsela ELA resources
Scary story writing lessons and resources
Use these linked lessons as a classroom sequence for teaching scary story writing from craft study through final revision.
Make scary story writing work beyond Halloween with Newsela Learning Suite
Scary story writing works because it gives students a reason to use what they know, not just what they can imagine. Plots and details that include a haunted train ride, a strange invention, or a storm brewing all get stronger when students have background knowledge to draw on.
Newsela Learning Suite can help extend this background knowledge beyond ELA and writing. Social Studies and STEM resources help students understand time, place, technology, nature, or the consequences of human choices. Across the suite, students can research, explore, discuss, and then turn that knowledge into stronger writing.
Not a Newsela customer yet? Sign up for free to start your 45-day trial and give students access to ELA, social studies, and STEM resources that help them research, explore, and bring stronger context to their writing.
Everything you need to accelerate learning across ELA, social studies, and science
How To Teach Scary Story Writing for Halloween and BeyondTeach scary story writing with mentor texts, suspense strategies, plot planning, descriptive revision, and age-appropriate Halloween alternatives.Sep 28, 2026Sep 28, 2026https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/66f182e7ce15762d01b32e09/6abaa1c3903937f52b69e1c4_Scary%20Story%20Writing%20Blog%20Hero%20Image.jpghttps://cdn.prod.website-files.com/66f182e7ce15762d01b32e09/6abaa1c67fd34eccb7d61bcc_Scary%20Story%20Writing%20Blog%20Hero%20Image%20(1).jpgChristy Walters
Products Overview
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
