The District

PD pitfalls to avoid

The Newsela Team
Nov 13, 2020

Potential risks educators should consider when implementing PD

It seems like it should be easy for educators to teach other educators. After all, administrators and teachers choose this profession because they understand the importance of learning and the value of delivering knowledge meaningfully and memorably. Continuing learning is essential for all teachers, and teachers who are always learning and improving their practice model that same growth mindset for their students. For a group of professionals with this mentality, creating effective professional development (PD) programs should be a smooth process — but at most schools, it’s not that simple. Despite the availability of great PD resources, many schools struggle to overcome the obstacles and implement PD that truly benefits teachers and students. 

Ninety percent of teachers receive workshop-style PD sessions during the school year. The problem? Most teachers believe these workshops are ineffective — and the scholarly literature backs them up. Studies from the 1980s to the present have shown over and over that teachers who receive PD through workshops don’t implement what they learn, and their students don’t improve their performance.

Lack of differentiation

Those results are concerning, but not surprising given the drawbacks of the self-contained workshop format. As teacher and math coach Pauline Zdonek put it in a column for Edutopia:

“The majority of PDs I attend are repetitive, simplistic, or downright boring.” 

Even for great administrators and educators, one-off workshops and lectures are difficult to differentiate and follow up on. 

The best educators understand the importance of differentiation, and they would never subject their students to undifferentiated lessons. The same principle applies to PD. PD sessions that put experienced teachers in the same workshop as new or struggling ones serve no one: Teachers who know the workshop’s concepts will be bored and feel their time is being wasted, and newer teachers may struggle to keep up — or worse, feel their unique needs, interests, and challenges are not being addressed. It only exacerbates this problem when administrators and consultants design PD curriculum without input from teachers. 

Just as problematically, the single-workshop model is unsuited to accountability: It usually leaves implementation up to individual teachers. Even for those teachers who do find the workshop’s content relevant and useful, one session cannot provide sufficient support to implement new strategies effectively. 

Growing pains for edtech PD

This is a big issue in an era when the topics PD covers are more complex than ever. PD sessions are an important tool in adopting edtech solutions, but the workshop model just isn’t right for many of the newest platforms. Many educators are resistant to edtech because they see it as too complicated — and who can blame them when they don’t have access to the resources and training they need to learn it?  

Unfortunately, edtech tends to be taught in “tech PD sessions” that are not segmented by subject — even though many of edtech’s most powerful applications are subject-specific. For instance, ELA and social studies teachers might use the same collaboration tools — but social studies teachers might benefit more from research and multimedia applications, while ELA teachers should focus on ways they can use these tools for writing projects. When the two groups are forced into one PD session, one or both will miss out on the best applications for their needs. Implementing tech tools and maximizing their effectiveness requires skill, practice, and ongoing support — not just one (possibly boring) lecture.

On a related note, many tech PD sessions tend to focus heavily on products and features rather than applications and skills. Teachers leave the sessions as experts on what a technology is and does, but might still be in the dark about how they can personally put it to work in their classrooms. PD sessions should engage teachers in active, collaborative learning centered on their unique learning goals for their students. Ultimately, edtech tools are a means to that end — and when they are introduced this way, a greater focus on applications will naturally follow. 

What administrators can do

If the workshop model is so ineffective, why do schools still use it? As with many challenges in education, the answer lies in limited resources. Administrators often perceive one-size-fits-all workshops as the simplest and least demanding form of PD — but while it may require the least investment up front, it’s vastly inefficient when you consider the low return on that investment. 

Fortunately, reimagining PD is possible, even for schools with limited resources. Administrators can draw on resources like Newsela’s Educator Center, adopt flexible formats that go beyond the standard workshop model, and collect teacher feedback and requests to determine curriculum. Increasingly, the best PD strategies include on-demand resources that teachers can access on their own time and at their own pace. By providing continuous access to PD knowledge, on-demand resources can provide teachers with foundational support while freeing up administrator time and resources. 

Supporting teachers as they implement PD concepts doesn’t need to be expensive or time-consuming: It can be as simple as accountability sessions, designing multi-session PD curricula around the same topic, or supporting existing curricula with on-demand resources. Engaged, interested teachers produce passionate, high-achieving students — and improving PD is a great way to spark that engagement. 

Check out our latest infographic, PD that innovates, to learn more about PD do’s and don'ts. 

The Latest from @Newsela

Newsela is proud to offer diverse perspectives so that all students can see themselves and their communities reflected in what they read. This article depicts one refugee family's experience in the U.S.
March 2, 2021, 8:38 PM
While the American frontier was thought to have been male-dominated, scholars teach us that women were a big part of the picture. Tell the complete story in your classroom by highlighting seven of the gutsiest women on the American frontier.
March 2, 2021, 8:34 PM
The themes of #WomensHistoryMonth should be ingrained in curriculum year-long. Yes Yes Yes ⬇️ ⬇️ ⬇️
March 2, 2021, 5:51 PM
Anne Hutchinson was a bold and intelligent woman, who became a leader at a time when women were not allowed to speak in public. Explore her life & trials with your students, and discuss: How could Hutchinson be considered a role model for other women?
March 2, 2021, 2:31 PM
How can we leverage social studies instruction to create structural and systemic change? Learn from educators across Pennsylvania by viewing the roundtable discussion here:
March 1, 2021, 8:03 PM
Which of these #WomensHistoryMonth Text Sets are you most excited to share with your students?
March 1, 2021, 5:17 PM
This #WomensHistoryMonth, help students discover the often overlooked female leaders of the American Revolution. These women wrote powerful literary works, mobilized colonists against injustice, and more—despite living in a staunchly patriarchal society.
March 1, 2021, 1:08 PM
Women are leaders. Women are innovative. ⁠Women are resourceful. ⁠ Women are courageous. ⁠ Women are strong. ⁠⁠ We'll be providing free #WomensHistoryMonth resources throughout the month of March. Please visit our homepage for the latest content:
March 1, 2021, 12:07 AM
Visit the Newsela Social Studies page to access a variety of always up-to-date resources to help you with teaching – whether you're using a remote, in-person, or hybrid approach to learning 👉
February 28, 2021, 11:20 PM
Many are beginning to question some of the myths told about U.S. history. Once you understand that complicated history, the question becomes: What can you do to help fix some of these historical wrongs?
February 28, 2021, 10:07 PM
Black women played critical roles in organizing, strategizing and putting their lives on the line for political freedom. Black women — even during slavery — planned resistance movements and organized for freedom.
February 28, 2021, 9:03 PM
Let's make it official! 🎓 Become a Newsela Certified Educator to build your expertise in designing creative teaching strategies with Newsela's instructional content—plus earn 5 hours of PD! ⭐
February 28, 2021, 6:15 PM
Are you addressing challenging and complex issues in the classroom, like racism or global warming? We recently surveyed over 2,600 educators. Here's what they had to say on this topic, and more:
February 28, 2021, 2:41 PM
Rotary phones and typewriters may be "so last century", but they'll always have a place in our hearts! Teach students about technology of the past using this article:
February 28, 2021, 12:07 AM

The best lessons start with the best content.

Ready to bring great instructional content to your students?

Contact Sales